Yakkstr

How do you decide if something is immoral?

if you are asked if A is immoral or moral, how do you decide?

Here are some examples:

Is it immoral to have a figurine of Buddha in your house?

Is it immoral to use contraception?

Is it immoral to be gay?

Is it immoral to have a tattoo?

report |
queenparanoia said 4 months ago ...

no to all... and yeah i was raised catholic and still is... being moral depends on the person and not by the book or what religion says.... for me religion is just a way to connect yourself to the higher power. after all, faith is you personal relationship to God.

sean_renaud said 4 months ago ...

While I'll fully admit that I work on for a lack of better terms a growing circle of me, ergo something is increasingly good or bad by how it effects me, and while I ultimately value long game over short game. The general rule is that good things create or preserve, bad thingds destroy. Nothing you've suggested is destructive in the least (well the tattoo might be bad for your career, good luck getting into office with that tribal on your face) so they are basically inherently neutral.

starchini said 4 months ago ...

As cheesy as it sounds my heart tells me. When faced with a decision or choice, I either get nauseas and feel sick or I feel happy about it. Whatever decision doesnt turn my stomache to concrete or make my heart hurt is the right decision.

and no non of those things I consider immoral.

queenparanoia said 4 months ago ...

starchini: your guts is one of the best barometer when it comes to morality. its what makes us different from other animals or perhaps more like them. our instincts tells us if it is good or not... :-)

sean_renaud said 4 months ago ...

Not sure if I agree there. Guts are great when you don't have time to think about it but if you do have time to think about it there should be parameters that go above and beyond what you think initially.

starchini said 4 months ago ...

I don't mean initially, as I think things over my feelings change, its always important to think of all possible outcomes consequences implications...a feeling for every category, if any of those feelings are negative you gotta weigh them out and decides whats me most important. Say finding a fifty dollar bill and no one is around, I feel great about this...finding a fifty with a delinquent water bill attached to it....I don't feel so great about keeping it, is take it to the water place and pay the bill...but the feelings are the answers to the logic. Based on the kind of person you are and how deeply you feel are to blame for out logical actions.

outlander said 4 months ago ...

Morality is the determining the difference between what is good and what is bad based on actions, intentions, and choices we make. What makes this a great topic is defining what is bad and what is good. Sometimes the line is blurred between the two and what is good and bad may be vastly different.

I think there are universal moral norms that dictate certain things are almost always 100% bad. Murder, rape, pedephilia, lies, torture, and stealing are examples.

We decide what is immoral by our cultural norms and our upbringing so the question what is immoral on a specific basis is difficult because we have all been raised differently. Someone from the west may think shooting a dear is disgustingly immoral while someone living in the deep south would think gay male sex is immoral.

reckoner said 4 months ago ...

"We decide what is immoral by our cultural norms"

Exactly, this is the point I've tried to make before, but the context was a bit different. I tried to avoid that context in this post. I'll add it later :)

Join our friendly Yakkstr community in 1 Easy Step
  • Meet Like Minded People
  • Share your thoughts with others who share your interests
  • No assholes to deal with, we keep them out
Join Now by writing your first comment below


Related Posts

Remember me

New? Sign up here.
reckoner commented about 4 hours ago on
This Obama's Gay Marriage Change Help Him?
I've got an invisible dragon in my garage. Just because you can't find it doesn't mean it doesn't exist. I'm happy to have a debate between the party that wants to spend trillions fighting a war about WMD that no one can find, and the party that read the rest
reckoner commented about 12 hours ago on
This Obama's Gay Marriage Change Help Him?
There were no WMDs in read the rest
reckoner commented about 22 hours ago on
ATTN MEN ... and ladies
Maybe he feels read the rest
reckoner commented 2 days ago on
what do you think.
I have a rare eye disease that dramatically affects my vision. I can't see very well out if my right eye, yet I have a happy fulfilling life so I can't complain read the rest
reckoner commented 3 days ago on
This Obama's Gay Marriage Change Help Him?
Rumsfeld "We know where they [Iraq's WMD] are. They're in the area around Tikrit and Baghdad and east, west, south, and north somewhat" Dick Cheney "Simply stated, there is no doubt that Saddam Hussein now has weapons of mass destruction." Ari read the rest
reckoner commented 3 days ago on
This Obama's Gay Marriage Change Help Him?
who was running the country when GW was pretending to be a fighter pilot landing a plane on an aircraft carrier under a "mission accomplished? sign? Who was running the country on 9/11 when he was reading books to school kids? Who was running the country read the rest
reckoner commented 3 days ago on
This Obama's Gay Marriage Change Help Him?
i'd rather vote for the guy buying off students than the guy buying off the top 1% with tax cuts that aren't paid read the rest
reckoner commented 4 days ago on
This Obama's Gay Marriage Change Help Him?
You left out the part about how a state amended it's constitution to deny legal rights to gay couples. I think that prompted a lot of read the rest
reckoner commented 5 days ago on
My favorite description of capitalism
"Tell that to people who rely on electricity to heat their homes, and have actual winter weather. " Let's be honest. Many of these people have homes that are far larger than they need. My house is 1200 sq ft, and that's including the garage. How big read the rest