Yakkstr

Intelligent Design...

Intelligent design (ID) is the proposition that "certain features of the universe and of living things are best explained by an intelligent cause, not an undirected process such as natural selection." It is a form of creationism and a contemporary adaptation of the traditional teleological argument for the existence of God, presented by its advocates as "an evidence-based scientific theory about life's origins" rather than "a religious-based idea". The leading proponents of intelligent design are associated with the Discovery Institute, a politically conservative think tank, and believe the designer to be the Christian God.

I've been giving this whole Intelligent Design idea some thought recently, now that I have been debating this issue with some of the esteemed members of this particular site. I've been looking at it in all sorts of different perspectives. Being a moral relativist that I am, I tried to look at it from as many different perspectives as possible. The conclusion that I came up with is that it's not science. It's not even bad science, it's not science at all. It's just hogwash. Children should not be taught this nonsense in schools.

Look. If you feel that evolution paints an incomplete picture of the nature of universe and our being and all that, that's fine. You're not alone in feeling this way. That doesn't mean you get to just make stuff up and try to teach nonsense to kids like it's fact, or studied in depth, even.

Here's the thing.

Intelligent Design and Creationism is an affront to God. If you believe in God, you should be offended that this nonsense prevails in modern culture. Intelligent Design and Creationism denies the grandeur of God. It does not extol the glory of God, but it denies it. Intelligent Design and Creationism claims that man can know and understand God's magnificence. Anyone that claims that mankind can understand God's Mysterious Works and how God developed the Universe is a heretic.

When you say the Earth is 6,000 years old you are saying that you know how God did it. This is one of the most egregious insults to God I have ever heard. It is basically saying that God is a technician and you can understand his work. You can understand how people, inspired by God thousands of years ago to write the Bible, fully understood what God was trying to tell them. That they had the ability to know God, to know God's thoughts, desires and wishes.

Look. The ones who believe in Intelligent Design and Creationism, the trail they think they're following is one that man created. God already gave us the tools to explore and study His Handiwork. It's called chemistry, it's called physics, it's called biology. Electronics, engineering, the hard sciences. These are the tools that God gave us to explore the universe, so that we may take delight and marvel at his work. These are the tools God used to craft the world. God gave us the ability to learn and study and make use of His Gifts.

God gave man the gift of Free Will and Intelligence did He not? God created the sciences so that man could create cities, and medicine, and advanced Agriculture techniques so that the planet could hold more in His Name. This too, Evolution. That was how God created man. God doesn't care about human time, to think God does is insulting to God. Trillions of years to us is nothing to God.

We cannot understand His reasons but we can study what he did. Those that say that they know how God did it. That says they believe themselves to be on an equal plane with God, to know God's designs.

Intelligent Design and Creationism denies God's Handiwork. It denies how God really created us and the universe and instead takes a bunch of crap people made up and said "here, this is how God did it." It's utter nonsense. Rubbish. It's heresy! They should be burned at the stake.

God created everything. That means God created the science you abhor. Those were the tools that God created and then used to craft His universe.

Why would you then deny them?

report |
rollingc said 4 months ago ...

Ignorance, pride, stubbornness...are some of the reasons that people deny the existence of God and His marvelous works. Until one learns humility and embraces acceptance of the things that are unexplainable to him (and others) you really cannot open the door wide enough for God to come into your life.

sadsack said 4 months ago ...

Human intelligence is as much a miracle as anything else in this universe.. Science is mankind's attempt to make sense of the world around us...that we have understood so much about the world is wonderful, but as Newton himself remarked, "I feel like a child on the sea-shore, marveling at a beautiful shell, while the whole ocean of truth lies undiscovered in front of me...' or words to that effect. The very fact that the universe obeys laws that can be beautifully stated using mathematics means, to me at least, that the universe is not just an accidental result of millenia of chaos, but a deliberate act of creation, of love. The universe is so completely awe-inspiring that to try to explain the mind of the Creator really is heresy.

lucyt said 4 months ago ...

which bloody god are you talking about ??????

grapekoolaid said 4 months ago ...

rc: One of my old college profs worked on the Manhattan project, was an incredible physicist (was also a beast of a football player) and an ordained Lutheran minister. He didn't see a cognitive dissonance in that at all. He was exploring his God's wonder.

sadsack: Yes. Awareness is in itself a powerful thing. The jury's still out on the grand intelligence for me. I'm leaning towards not. Even if there were, I doubt it's even concerned with something so insignificance as us.

lucy: Whichever god you pray to, of course. :)

lucyt said 4 months ago ...

I'm suppose to pray??

Man I've been doing it all wrong....

Here I thought I was in control of my destiny, you know free will and all that.

grapekoolaid said 4 months ago ...

Are you telling me you don't appeal to a higher power? You don't throw a message out into the universe to anyone who'll listen? :)

lucyt said 4 months ago ...

yes all the time, but really I'm talking to myself. *-)

grapekoolaid said 4 months ago ...

I know what you mean. Like I said somewhere before, I send my notes out on to the universe, but they seldom listen. I just wanted to outline this whole ID nonsense from a theological perspective. Being a moral relativist allows me to look at subjects from a myriad of perspectives. :)

outlander said 4 months ago ...

Google the word science and when you find the wiki page read it. What I find amazing is right now as you ar reading this comment from a computer or labtop or whatever, you wholeheartedly believe some ancestor from some creature eventually over the course of zillions of years brought about the design of the device you are using by a random set of circumstances but the even a mention that design fits easier than random and here comes the religious slurs. You know ID is not creationism, ID is used in many different types of sciences and supported by a lot of people that are smarter than both me an you.

Here's how you can help yourself. Try to prove ID is a science instead of haphazardly throwing it under a bus.

I have spent years trying to prove evolution and it is always the same exact thing, lots of talk with little evidence. ID doesn't disprove or replace evolution, it just fills in some of the holes evolution leaves behind.

grapekoolaid said 4 months ago ...

The fact that we have cities and cars, (though not yet flying) doesn't require me to believe in a designer of any kind. It speaks of human ingenuity. The fact that life has evolved to such a complicated organisms like ourselves are completely within the realms of possibilities. It very easily can be a grand cosmic accident.

In cosmological time, human history is just a blip. Not even a blink of an eye. It's within the realms of possibility that we're nothing but a dream of a sleeping giant, a god, or a butterfly. The can be one and the same as well.

I apologize if you feel that I have offended you in some way. It was never my intention to use slurs of any kind, religious or secular. If I had used a word inappropriately, it was probably in the heat of the moment and while I do apologize, you should also take delight in knowing that your words contain enough power to get someone all riled up. Don't even get me started on the power of words.

I mean, look at the series of posts that you and I have written in conversation with one another. That means that in certain degrees (shudder to think) that you have been my muse and I yours. :P

The burden of proof (that ID is a science) is on the proponents of ID, not skeptics.

I've said this before, too. I agree with you that evolution paints an "incomplete" picture of sorts. But that's not because the theory itself is incomplete. The data set with which we are working with is not expansive enough. I gather that will change now with the human genome project and all.

outlander said 4 months ago ...

Brilliant, very well said. And certainly I can be a dink. But here in lies the fork in the road between us, it is easier for me to believe in a higher power versus a cosmic accident and this is mainly based on the unexplained and the miraculous.

grapekoolaid said 4 months ago ...

I understand your position quite well. I don't, however, want God to be an ever diminishing window of unexplained phenomena. God has to be more than just cover "what we don't know", because that is not sufficient. Until we discovered electromagnetism and its effects on climate science, we thought that thunder and lightening was God's anger.

Some still believe that tornadoes (and Katrina, too) are God's punishment for the wicked people on this earth. While I agree that trailer parks can be dens of inequity and villainy, there's a reason why there's a tornado season and it usually strikes in tornado alley. It's not because people in Joplin Missouri were particularly bad. (Though they could be, you never know)

Join our friendly Yakkstr community in 1 Easy Step
  • Meet Like Minded People
  • Share your thoughts with others who share your interests
  • No assholes to deal with, we keep them out
Join Now by writing your first comment below


Related Posts
Intelligent Design and Evolution
This is a fascinating video which makes a great argument that hasn't come up yet in our recent discussions of ID and evolution. Take 10 minutes and watch it :)
1 comment
last by outlander 4 months ago
If evolution is wrong, what is right?
Whenever I ask for an alternative theory that fits the evidence I get crickets. No critic of evolution has an alternative that fits the evidence better than evolution. This shows the fundamental flaw in Intelligent Design. There is NO theory of ID that
30 comments Last Page
last by wombat 4 months ago

Remember me

New? Sign up here.
grapekoolaid commented 3 days ago on
Just kill it!
I'm alright with it if it's anything like read the rest
grapekoolaid commented 3 days ago on
Lulls and Rubs
Darn tootin' Uni! You're preachin' to the choir over here! Testify!!! :D You can either refuse to have that religious talk with Valentine, or you can have that one *serious* conversation with him. Even better, convert him to atheism! :D Don't read the rest
grapekoolaid commented 3 days ago on
4 day count down - annoyance #2
Oh I'm sure you'll turn some heads. :) Just a point of clarification, though. The look you're going for is a Saudi woman *outside* of Saudi Arabia. Because if you were in Saudi Arabia, you'd be in an abaya, or a read the rest
grapekoolaid commented 3 days ago on
5 day count down - just to annoy ~
Dammit, the video didn't link to the proper time. Please skip to 2 minutes and 28 seconds on the read the rest
grapekoolaid commented 3 days ago on
5 day count down - just to annoy ~
Oh and I thought about [this](http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Zr162OZ2Z0w#t2m28s) when you said that doing nothing is like a jail sentence. read the rest
grapekoolaid commented 3 days ago on
Awful ~
I usually frown and just shake my really slowly. That shuts the kid up pretty quick. And yep. Condensed milk. That's what makes Vietnamese coffee. read the rest
grapekoolaid commented 3 days ago on
5 day count down - just to annoy ~
Oh come now. To spend a day with nothing to do with someone you enjoy spending time with is my idea of heaven. Just to sit around enjoying each other's company? It's divine~~~ I look forward to your pictures. read the rest
grapekoolaid commented 3 days ago on
This Obama's Gay Marriage Change Help Him?
"Can we all just agree that Obama is a liar?" Unlike any other politician, right? Certainly none from your camp. read the rest
grapekoolaid commented 3 days ago on
Last week's Supermoon!!!
wombie: You'll have to enlighten me on your dirty-minded snorting fit, because I don't get it. I can be pretty oblivious to things sometimes. *Oh and a point of correction:* While it is true that B asked me to come down to see the supermoon that read the rest
grapekoolaid commented 3 days ago on
Awful ~
Mmm... Yes... Vietnamese iced coffee... That does sound really good right now... Unfortunately, I can't have any of that delightful ambrosia, the nectar of the gods until I meet up with my friend B. Her and I are making plans to make a purple sweet read the rest